FinanceLane
  • Funding
    • Equity Funding
    • Debt Funding
    • Crowdfunding
    • Real Estate Funding
  • Investing
    • Stocks
    • Bonds
    • Mutual Funds
    • Commodities
    • Forex
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Crypto Investing
  • Lending
    • Personal Loan
    • Business Loan
    • Mortgage
    • Credit Card
    • Microfinance
    • Peer-to-Peer Lending
  • Insurance
    • Life Insurance
    • Health Insurance
    • Auto Insurance
    • Education Insurance
    • General Insurance
  • Banking
    • Individual Banking
    • Business Banking
    • Investment Banking
    • Neo Banking
    • Payments Bank
  • Wealth
    • Earning
    • Savings
    • Investments
    • Budgeting
    • Credit Management
    • Tax Planning
    • Retirement
  • Fintech
    • Payments
    • Digital Banks
    • Alternative Financing
    • Asset Management
    • Softwares
  • Startup
    • Startup Ecosystem
    • Merging & Acquisition
    • Equity Investing
    • Franchising
    • Business Offers
  • Crypto
    • Crypto Coins
    • Crypto Trading
    • Bitcoin
    • Blockchain
    • DAPP
    • Crypto Investing
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
FinanceLane
  • Home
  • Funding
  • Investing
  • Lending
  • Insurance
  • Banking
  • Wealth
  • Crypto
  • Newsletters
  • Feedback
Home News Feed Advisory

Health insurance claim rejection due to non-disclosure of material alcoholism is valid, rules SC

FinanceLaneby FinanceLane
March 26, 2025

In a recent verdict, the Supreme Court ruled that health insurers have valid grounds to repudiate or reject any health-insurance claims that stem from alcoholism if the individual did not explicitly disclose that they consume alcohol while buying the insurance policy. In this case, the apex court held LIC’s (Life Insurance Corporation) claim to reject an individual’s hospitalization claim under their now-discontinued Jeevan Arogya scheme (a health insurance benefit-based policy) since he had not apprised LIC of his chronic alcoholism.
The Supreme Court upheld the decision of the LIC to repudiate a claim over the hospitalisation of a policyholder under the “Jeevan Arogya” scheme since he gave false information regarding his habit of alcohol consumption. The individual had remained hospitalized for nearly a month after complaining of severe abdominal pain before succumbing to a cardiac arrest.
“The deceased provided false information in the proposal form. The relevant question in the form asked, “Does the life insured consume alcohol/cigarettes/bidis/or tobacco in any form?” The deceased answered, “No.” The policy was issued based on this declaration. However, evidence on record establishes that the deceased was a chronic alcoholic. This fact was not disclosed at the time of obtaining the policy,” the judgment noted.

Complete disclosure on behalf of the policyholder becomes all the more important under schemes such as Jeevan Arogya since they are issued under a Non-Medical General Scheme, i.e., where no medical examinations are conducted before issuing a policy.


Lower courts and dispute redressal commissions approached by the aggrieved’s wife had rejected the aforementioned hospital note regarding the policyholder’s chronic alcohol intake because the LIC policy had been purchased a year that it was issued a year after the policy was taken.Also Read: Your life insurance claim may be rejected if you take a new plan without declaring the ones you already have, says SC

However, in the words of the Supreme Court, “chronic liver disease, caused by prolonged alcohol consumption, does not develop overnight. The deceased’s alcoholism was a longstanding condition, which he knowingly suppressed while subscribing to the policy. Given this suppression of material facts, the appellant was justified in repudiating the claim under the exclusion clause.”
Notably, clause 7(xi) of the Jeevan Arogya plan explicitly excludes coverage for “self-afflicted injuries or conditions (attempted suicide) and/or the use or misuse of any drugs or alcohol and complications arising from it.”

Explains Monark Gahlot, Partner, Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas, “each case of non-disclosure in insurance policies must be assessed on its specific facts. Concealment of a disease unrelated to the death, or disclosure that is not material enough to influence the insurer’s acceptance of risk, may be available as a defense to the insured.

Can my claim be rejected if I do not disclose my drinking habits to my insurer?

In the case of Sulbha Prakash Motegaoneker & Ors. v. Life Insurance Corporation (2015), the SC held that simple suppression or nondisclosure of a pre-existing disease is not grounds enough to reject a claim.

Hence, on the face of it, your insurer cannot reject your claim simply because you did not disclose the fact that you consume alcohol.

However, there has to be a clear establishment of the fact that the cause of death or hospitalization was not directly linked to such a concealed pre-existing disease. So, say you were hospitalized for a brain hemorrhage and filed a claim regarding this.

Also Read: Latest claim settlement ratio of health and general insurance companies released by IRDA in 2025, Navi, Acko take lead, Star Health, Zuno fall below 90%

For the insurer to reject this claim on the grounds of your not disclosing your alcohol consumption, they will have to assertively establish first that this hospitalization was directly caused by your drinking alcohol.

Notes Aslam Ahmed, Partner, Singhania & Co., “Only material non-disclosures—those that would have influenced the insurer’s decision to issue the policy or determine its terms—can justify claim repudiation. If a policyholder is an infrequent or social drinker and does not disclose this fact, the insurer must establish that the omission was material. We believe that if occasional drinking had no impact on the claimed illness, the insurer may not have valid grounds for rejection.”

However, if this drinking, irrespective of its frequency, worsened a pre-existing condition or was a factor in hospitalization, the claim could be denied.

Ankit Rajgarhia, Principal Associate, Karanjawala & Co., concurs. According to him, if a policyholder is a social or infrequent drinker but did not disclose this while buying the policy, the insurer may still contest the claim. But the key legal ground is materiality—whether the omission influenced the insurer’s risk assessment.

“Sporadic drinking may not always justify repudiation unless it directly caused the claimed illness,” he adds.

All in all, as Alay Razvi, Managing Partner, Accord Juris, underlines, for the insurer to reject a claim, they must prove that the non-disclosure was material and that it would have influenced the underwriting decision. Infrequent or social drinking, unless medically relevant, shouldn’t automatically be treated as material suppression.

How do insurance companies determine materiality?

Your claim can be rejected based on how material, or significant, your non-disclosure of a particular habit like drinking was in contributing to the condition that led you to file a claim. So, if you did not disclose a particular condition while buying a policy, the insurer has no grounds to reject your claim till it does not determine a clear cause-and-effect relationship between your non-disclosed habits and the claim you’ve filed.

Insurers generally rely on medical records, prescriptions, and circumstantial evidence (e.g., hospital notes mentioning alcohol history) to establish a link between the undisclosed habit and the claim. In chronic conditions like liver diseases, which develop over time, even old medical records are relevant.

Source Link

Related Topics

Advisory

Here’s how you can protect your turf at work

Advisory

What should FD investors do now? RBI cuts repo rate by 50 bps, interest rates will fall further

Prev Next

You May Like

Advisory

Here’s how you can protect your turf at work

Advisory

What should FD investors do now? RBI cuts repo rate by 50 bps, interest rates will fall further

Advisory

Big savings for home loan borrowers as EMIs to fall significantly after RBI cuts repo rate by 50 bps

Advisory

Bakrid bank holiday today: Are banks open or closed in your state on June 6, 2025 for Id-ul-Ad’ha 2025

Advisory

HDFC Bank UPI and other services won’t be available on this date: Check details here

Advisory

Waiting list train ticket? Get ticket confirmation assurance with up to 3x money back guarantee from Ixigo, Redbus and MakeMyTrip

Advisory

Bank holiday on June 6, 2025 and June 7, 2025: Are banks closed tomorrow in your state for Bakrid?

Advisory

5 things you’re probably doing, that are pushing away success at your job

Financial News

Advisory

Apollo SBI Card SELECT Card: Check rewards points, free health check-ups, complimentary lounge access details

FinanceLane
by FinanceLane
Advisory

New e-Zero FIR: Govt launches pilot project for swift action against cybercrimes; how it can help you

FinanceLane
by FinanceLane
Investing

How to manage gilt mutual funds as I approach retirement?

FinanceLane
by FinanceLane
Advisory

Budget 2025: Higher 87A tax rebate, deduction on home loan, income tax slab and more, what experts demand from FM to boost consumption

FinanceLane
by FinanceLane
Blockchain News

dYdX Unveils Isolated Markets and Margin for Enhanced Trading Flexibility

Blockchain
by Blockchain
Blockchain News

NVIDIA Expands AI Training with Multilingual Workshop at GTC Paris

Blockchain
by Blockchain
Advisory

5 major EPF changes in 2025: Easy PF transfer, joint declaration process, CPPS, pension for higher wages and more

FinanceLane
by FinanceLane
Advisory

Does IFSC Code for IMPS,RTGS,NEFT change when the bank changes its name? Here’s what you need to know

FinanceLane
by FinanceLane
Advisory

Top 5 large and mid-cap funds with up to 29.24% returns in 5 years, as on April 30, 2025

FinanceLane
by FinanceLane
Blockchain News

BitMEX Introduces HYPERUSDT Perpetual Swaps with 50x Leverage

Blockchain
by Blockchain
Blockchain News

Open Source Evolution: Security, AI, and Diversity Drive Growth

Blockchain
by Blockchain
Blockchain News

BNB Chain Unveils Winners of Latest AI Hackathon Batch

Blockchain
by Blockchain
Load More
FinanceLane.com
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Subscribe
  • Contact

Subscribe to get the latest updates

Follow us on

© 2022 FinanceLane.com. All rights reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Google
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
  • Home
  • Funding
    • Equity Funding
    • Debt Funding
    • Real Estate Funding
    • Crowdfunding
  • Investing
    • Stocks
    • Bonds
    • Mutual Funds
    • Private Equity
    • Merging & Acquisition
    • Real Estate
  • Lending
    • Personal Loan
    • Business Loan
    • Credit Card
    • Microfinance
    • Peer-to-Peer Lending
  • Insurance
    • Life Insurance
    • Auto Insurance
    • Education Insurance
    • Health Insurance
  • Banking
    • Business Banking
    • Payments Bank
    • Investment Banking
    • Individual Banking
  • Wealth
    • Earning
    • Savings
    • Investments
    • Budgeting
    • Credit Management
    • Tax Planning
    • Retirement
  • Fintech
    • Alternative Financing
    • Payments
    • Asset Management
    • Digital Banks
    • Softwares
  • Fintech
    • Alternative Financing
    • Asset Management
    • Digital Banks
    • Softwares
    • Payments
  • Crypto
    • Crypto Investing
    • Crypto Trading
    • Crypto Coins
    • Bitcoin
    • Blockchain
    • DAPP
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Login

© 2022 FinanceLane - Terms and Conditions | Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.